10 min read
May 18, 2022

Concrete screws vs wedge anchors vs throughbolts: how to choose

Image of Scott Humphris
Scott Humphris
Installing a concrete anchor through a metal support bracket
Back to blog

Concrete screws, wedge anchors and throughbolts all connect a fixture or support to concrete, but they work in different ways. The right choice depends on the substrate, the load, the fixture, the anchor approval and the installation method.

This guide compares the three types and sets out the checks to make before drilling. Use the current product data, installation instructions and project specification for the fixing selected.

Download this article as a guide

Contents

Why anchors and fixings matter

An anchor transfers load from a fixture or support into its substrate. It may be a small component, but the connection depends on the anchor being suitable for the job and installed as specified.

Performance depends on more than the anchor name. The substrate, its condition, the load, the fixture thickness, hole diameter and depth, spacing, edge distances and installation method all matter. A different anchor type is not automatically a suitable substitute.

After installation, anchors can be hidden by concrete, services or suspended ceilings, so damage or deterioration may not be easy to see. An anchor also forms part of a support system. If one fixing fails, load can move to the remaining points and compromise the assembly. Overhead applications can put people and equipment below at risk, so follow the project design and the product instructions.

For the wider selection and installation framework, read the MIDFIX BS 8539 guide for M&E anchors. It explains the code-of-practice considerations for post-installed anchors.

Rotary hammer drilling into concrete for an anchor installation

Common drilling issues

Before drilling, find the installation information for the exact anchor. Check the product packaging, technical data sheet and manufacturer's instructions for the drill diameter, hole depth, cleaning method and setting or tightening requirements. If the required diameter or depth is not clear, stop and ask before carrying on.

Hitting reinforcement is another common problem. Stop drilling and seek advice from the responsible structural engineer or the person responsible for the design. Do not reduce the required embedment to get past the bar. Reposition only when the project instructions and the anchor manufacturer's repositioning guidance allow it. A product with a manufacturer-designed shallow embedment option may suit a planned detail, but it is not permission to alter an anchor after drilling.

The selected drill bit matters too. Use a sound bit of the specified type and diameter. Use a PGM-marked bit where the manufacturer's instructions call for one. Do not use a worn bit, as it can leave an inaccurate hole.

Wear the required PPE before drilling or installing any anchor. Keep the hole clear of dust using the cleaning method stated in the product instructions.

Quick comparison of concrete screws, wedge anchors and throughbolts

Here is a quick comparison of the anchor types covered in this guide:

Anchor typeHow it holdsSubstrates and checksTypical applications in this guide
Concrete screwInterlock. The thread cuts into the hole wall and forms a key.MIDFIX MCS-HX, MCS-LP and MCS-RH screws are for concrete only. Do not use them in brick, stone or block.Threaded rod hangers, slotted channel and baseplates, depending on the screw design.
Wedge anchorExpansion. A setting tool drives the internal cone to expand the anchor.The MIDFIX MWA is suitable for specific applications in cracked and non-cracked concrete. Confirm single or multiple fixing status and the exact approval.Suspending threaded rod and fixing fixtures to concrete.
ThroughboltTorque-controlled expansion. Tightening draws the taper into the expansion clip.Check the selected product's data for its approved concrete condition and installation requirements.Through-fixing fixtures and supports to concrete.

Concrete screws: what are they?

Concrete screws are interlock anchors. Their thread cuts into the substrate as the screw is installed. Screw designs differ by head, length and application, so choose the product for the fixture and the approved substrate rather than by appearance alone.

The MIDFIX MCS-HX, MCS-LP and MCS-RH screws are for concrete only. Do not use these MCS products in brick, stone or block. If your fixing is in brick, stone or block, select a separate fixing whose catalogue entry and current product data expressly cover that material and the installation conditions. Frame Screws are a separate MIDFIX range for concrete, brick and block. Frame Screws are a different product range, not an MCS screw.

MIDFIX's MCS-HX concrete screw is a hex-head option. It is a thread-cutting, non-expanding anchor with ETA approval for specified concrete applications. The MCS-LP concrete screw has a pan head and is used for fixing slotted channel. Browse the MIDFIX ETA anchor range to compare the current product options.

Concrete screw cross-section showing drill depth, embedment, hole diameter and fixture thickness

How do concrete screws work?

The screw's thread cuts into the hole wall as the anchor is driven. This creates the interlock that resists the load. The selected product's thread, diameter, embedment and installation requirements determine how the anchor performs.

The MCS-HX anchor is non-expanding and creates less stress in the substrate than an expanding anchor. That is a product-specific characteristic, not a spacing rule. Do not assume concrete screws can be placed closer together or nearer an edge without checking the relevant product data and design.

The head style also affects the job. A rod hanger, a low-profile head and a hex-head screw serve different fixing details. Choose by the fixture, required head clearance and approved application.

How do you install concrete screws?

The equipment and settings depend on the anchor. You may need:

  • A drilling machine and the correct drill bit.
  • A blow tool or the specified hole-cleaning equipment.
  • The correct socket or Torx bit for the anchor head.
  • An impact wrench or hand ratchet suited to the selected product.
  • The specified hole diameter and depth.
  • The manufacturer's installation torque value where one is specified.
  • PPE for drilling and installation.

Follow this sequence:

  1. Confirm the selected anchor is approved for the substrate, fixture, load and project detail. Read the current instructions before starting.
  2. Mark the fixing position and check that the specified edge distances and anchor spacing can be maintained.
  3. Drill to the stated diameter and depth with the correct bit. Keep the drill aligned with the fixing position.
  4. Clean the hole using the method stated by the manufacturer. Do not assume a hole is clean because the drill bit has been removed.
  5. Fit the correct driving bit. Use an impact wrench only where the product instructions allow it, and set the tool as specified.
  6. Drive the screw until it is seated as instructed. Do not keep tightening once the head or fixture has reached the stated position.
  7. If a torque value applies, use the specified value. Over-tightening can damage the thread cut into the concrete or prevent the screw from seating correctly.

Concrete screw installation sequence showing drilling, cleaning and driving the screw home

For hands-on installation training, see the MIDFIX Academy courses.

MIDFIX Academy anchor installation course

What are the different types of concrete screws?

Three types are commonly used in building services work:

  • Rod hangers: These are used to suspend M8 or M10 threaded rod from concrete ceilings. The current MIDFIX MCS-RH rod hanger page lists standard and short versions, with anchor lengths of 55 mm and 35 mm respectively. Check its approval and load data for the exact fixing detail.
  • Low-profile or pan-head screws: These can fix slotted channel back to concrete. The MCS-LP has a 17 mm pan head and TX30 drive. Its 6 x 28 mm and 6 x 40 mm options have product-specific maximum fixing thicknesses. Use the current MCS-LP product page for the exact item.
  • Hex-head screws: These are used for different fixture details, including baseplates where a throughbolt may otherwise be considered. The MCS-HX page lists cracked and non-cracked concrete applications under its product-specific ETA scope.

Three concrete screw styles: threaded rod hanger, low-profile head and hex head

The screw type, diameter, embedment and maximum fixture thickness all affect selection. Check the exact MIDFIX product page and technical data sheet before ordering or drilling.

Wedge anchors: what are they?

The MWA is a wedge anchor and a deformation-controlled expansion anchor: a manual or SDS setting tool drives its cone to expand the anchor. It has a rim for flush setting. This type is also known as a drop-in fastener. Check the MWA product data for product-specific fixing conditions in cracked and non-cracked concrete. Identify the exact anchor and follow its current instructions.

How do wedge anchors work?

For the MIDFIX MWA type, a setting tool drives the internal expansion cone into the anchor. This expands the anchor against the sides of the drilled hole and creates the resistance needed to hold the fixture.

Expansion places pressure on the surrounding concrete. Keep to the product's edge distances, spacing, embedment and setting requirements. Do not use the same assumptions for a different anchor, even if it looks similar.

Wedge anchor section and installed example showing an expansion plug in concrete

Section views of an expansion plug before and after the anchor is set

How do you install wedge anchors?

You may need:

  • A drilling machine and the specified drill bit.
  • A blow tool or hole-cleaning pump.
  • The correct hammer.
  • The anchor manufacturer's manual or automatic setting tool for the selected size.
  • A torque wrench for the fixture or set screw where the instructions specify a torque value.
  • The specified hole diameter and depth.
  • PPE.

Install the anchor in the order stated by the manufacturer:

  1. Drill the correct diameter and depth. Stop if reinforcement is encountered and get the responsible technical person to confirm the next step.
  2. Clean the hole using the stated method.
  3. Insert the anchor to the specified depth and use the setting tool intended for that anchor and size.
  4. If the anchor has a witness mark or visual setting indication, check it is visible and matches the instructions.
  5. If a set screw or fixture needs tightening, use the manufacturer's stated torque and a calibrated torque wrench where required.
  6. Check that the required edge distances and spacing have been maintained. Expansion anchors too close to an edge or to another anchor can damage the substrate or fail.

The setting tool is part of the installation. Use the manufacturer's recommended setting tool for the exact anchor and size. The MIDFIX MWA range has manual safety handles and matching SDS setting tools. Use the specified tool and follow its instructions for the required setting action.

The MIDFIX MSK Plug-on Setting Kit is one product-specific option. Check the tool page and anchor instructions to make sure it suits the anchor and application.

Anchor setting tool being driven into concrete with a hammer

MIDFIX Academy anchor installation course

Manual and SDS setting tools for anchors in concrete

What types of wedge anchors are available?

Wedge anchors differ by design, thread size, length, finish, setting method and maximum fixture thickness. Some have a rim or lip for flush setting; others do not. The ETA-approved version of the MIDFIX MWA is rimmed.

MIDFIX offers a 25 mm shallow embedment MWA option intended to reduce reinforcement hits. It is a product-specific design option. Do not change the required embedment or reposition a fixing on site without following the approval, installation instructions and project process.

Sizes and approvals are not interchangeable between products. Check whether the fixing is approved for the intended substrate and whether the approval is for a single or multiple fixing. The MIDFIX ETA anchor range shows the current options.

Wedge anchor on product approval documentation

Throughbolts: what are they?

A throughbolt is an expansion anchor tightened with torque. It is installed through the fixture and into the concrete. Tightening draws the expansion taper into the clip, which expands against the hole wall and creates a clamping force.

Throughbolt approvals are product-specific. Check the current ETA and product data for the exact product, size and concrete condition. Do not assume that every throughbolt has the same approval scope.

How do throughbolts work?

A throughbolt includes the nut, washer, main shank, expansion taper and expansion clip. Some versions also have depth marks on the threaded section.

As the nut is tightened, it draws the expansion taper into the clip. This expands the anchor and clamps the fixture against the substrate. The anchor relies on the combination of its approved design, correct hole, setting torque and installation method.

Throughbolt parts: nut, washer, depth marks, expansion clip and expansion taper

How do you install throughbolts?

For throughbolt installation, have a drilling machine, the correct drill bit, a socket and a calibrated torque wrench. Gather any cleaning or insertion tools specified in the selected product's instructions. Check the hole diameter, depth and setting torque before drilling.

Follow the exact instructions for the throughbolt selected:

  1. Drill the hole to the specified diameter and depth.
  2. Clean the hole using the method stated in the current instructions for that product.
  3. Insert the anchor through the fixture as instructed. Use a depth mark or setting position only where the product instructions specify it.
  4. Tighten to the manufacturer's stated torque using a calibrated torque wrench. The torque value is product-specific.
  5. Keep the fixture, edge distances and anchor spacing within the approved arrangement.
  6. Do not overtighten. More torque is not automatically safer; excess torque can overstress the anchor or damage the fixture. Too little torque can leave the fixture insecure.

Clamping force can relax after installation. The amount depends on the product and conditions, so use the manufacturer's current torque value and installation instructions. A torque value does not remove the need to use the right anchor and calibrated tool.

Throughbolt installation sequence: drill and clean the hole, insert the anchor and tighten it

Throughbolt diagram showing tensile and clamping forces alongside a torque wrench

Torque wrench tightening a throughbolt through a metal fixture into concrete

What types of throughbolts are available?

Throughbolts come in different diameters, lengths, maximum fixture thicknesses and finishes. The R-HPT zinc-flake throughbolt is approved under ETA-17/0184 for structural use in cracked and non-cracked concrete. Its sizes are M8 x 65 mm, M10 x 65, 80, 95 and 115 mm, and M12 x 80, 100 and 120 mm. Check the current product data for the exact item, including its corrosion protection, drill size and maximum fixture thickness.

How to choose an anchor

Before selecting or substituting an anchor, confirm:

  1. What the substrate is: concrete, solid brick or another material, and whether the concrete is cracked or non-cracked. The MCS-HX, MCS-LP and MCS-RH screws covered here are for concrete only.
  2. What is being fixed: the support or fixture, its thickness, position and the load direction.
  3. Which product approval applies: check the exact product, size, embedment, finish and approval conditions.
  4. How it must be installed: hole diameter and depth, cleaning, setting tool, torque and required inspection marks.
  5. What spacing and edge distances are available: compare them with the product data and design.
  6. Who must approve a change: ask the responsible designer or engineer before substituting an anchor or changing its position.

Do not select on diameter or product name alone. A similar-looking anchor can have a different approval or require a different setting tool. If reinforcement, unclear substrate or an unusual load affects the detail, pause and get the relevant technical approval before continuing.

For more context on approvals and selection, read the MIDFIX guide to ETA-approved anchors.

Frequently asked questions

Are concrete screws better than wedge anchors?

Neither is best for every job. A concrete screw cuts a thread into the substrate and relies on interlock. A wedge anchor expands against the hole wall when set with its specified tool. Compare the approval, substrate, load, fixture and installation requirements for the exact products.

Can MCS screws be used in brick, stone or block?

No. MCS-HX, MCS-LP and MCS-RH screws are for concrete only. Do not use them in brick, stone or block. For a masonry fixing, select a separate product whose data covers the actual unit and installation conditions. Frame Screws are a separate MIDFIX range for concrete, brick and block.

What should I do if the drill hits reinforcement?

Stop. Do not reduce embedment or move the fixing without approval. Ask the responsible structural engineer or designer and follow the anchor manufacturer's repositioning guidance. A shallow embedment product can be considered only where its approval and the design allow it.

Do throughbolts work in cracked concrete?

Some do. The MIDFIX R-HPT zinc-flake throughbolt is approved for structural use in cracked and non-cracked concrete under ETA-17/0184. Other throughbolt products have their own scope, so check the exact product and size before specifying it.

Do throughbolts need a torque wrench?

Use the torque method and value stated by the manufacturer. Use a calibrated torque wrench when installing throughbolts. Do not guess the setting or treat overtightening as extra security.

Conclusion

Concrete screws, wedge anchors and throughbolts have different installation methods and approval conditions. The practical checks are the same: identify the substrate, match the product to the fixture and load, confirm the hole and setting requirements, and follow the approved spacing and edge distances.

If the application or product choice is unclear, contact MIDFIX with the drawing, substrate details and fixing requirement. For further anchor reading, see the MIDFIX anchor articles or the MIDFIX Academy courses.